Of course, I had every intention of blogging about this party idea before the Christmas season was over. But, as with most people, when the holidays hit, they hit hard and there is little time for leisurely blogging. I’m not the first to write about this party idea, however, and certainly won’t be the last, so I’m sure if you wanted to have a Christmas Cookie Exchange, you would have already done so. I’d just like to offer my suggestions because for three years now, I’ve had decent success with my own.
My favorite, favorite, favorite party to host each year is an annual Christmas Cookie Party Exchange. Mine is ladies only, but of course, this could go co-ed just as easily. Part of my inspiration for making it ‘Ladies Only’ is owed to another friend who used to throw a Christmas “Hen” Party each year to which she would invite her girlfriends for snacks, cocktails and a gift exchange.
An Overview
Basically, I have each guest make about 2 and a half dozen cookies at home. They are to bring the cookies and the recipes they used so that each guest can take a variety of all of the cookies back home with them. I make all guests a cook book full of all the cookie recipes as well as recipes for any of the snacks I provide. In truth, this usually takes me until about the time the invites go out for the next cookie party. But, hey- they eventually go out.

The Food
Besides the obvious cookies, I actually make 4-5 appetizers so that no one goes into a sugar coma on my living room floor. My appetizer selection varies, but has included: warm mushroom cheese spread with bread, cheese balls and crackers, chicken and rice salad, hot spinach artichoke dip, curried chicken salad, etc. I also, besides having some beer and wine, I make one cocktail. My all time favorite is Alton Brown’s Egg Nog. And usually there are a few people scared to try it, but they come around. I will admit though, this is pretty much a custard and so it can be heavy. This year I made a cocktail with Prosseco, frozen cranberries, cranberry juice and triple sec instead. Proceed with caution.
The Activities
Rather than giving everyone gifts (although this year I did make cranberry apple butter for attendees), I typically buy craft supplies so that everyone can take home their own ornament as a souvenir. I also buy 3 door prizes to give out for winning games and making ornaments. One prize is given for the winner of Ice Breaker Bingo. It’s not as lame as it sounds and actually is a quick way for everyone to fast track the mingling without putting anyone on the spot. I found a template on-line and make my bingo cards according to my friends’ facts and interests.
bingo1
Of course, you have to take the same template and mix up some of the fact. It isn’t difficult, but it can be tedious, so I try to do the prep work for this as soon as I have all my RSVPs in. But what happens, every year, is that long after someone has shouted bingo, everyone keeps playing to fill up their cards and to get to know each other a little better.
Another activity we have going is making ornaments. I pull out some fabric, felt, glitter glue, buttons, paper, and many precut wooden or ceramic ornaments from Michael’s or Joanne’s that just need a little paint. So, the ambitious kids of the bunch can start cutting things out and sewing, while the less ambitious (I’m usually in this category on this particular night) can grab a paintbrush and open a few bottles. One thing that really helped this year was that I saw some “handmade” ornaments in my Crate and Barrel catalog I thought were cute and cut pictures out to help generate some ideas. The results were adorable.



I also ask the ladies to bring a handmade ornament from home to trim my tree with. This is optional, but I encourage participation by offering a prize to the best ornament, voted on by secret ballot. I’ve gotten some great ornaments over the years and it gives me a warm and fuzzy feeling to look at my tree and relive fond memories. The first year, I hadn’t thought to have everyone make their own ornaments from scratch. So, I found a Cookie Monster coloring page, shrunk it onto a post card and suggested ladies decorate their Cookie Monster to be judged. I may go back to this format, or offer it as an option again as it produced more ornaments.
Door prizes have included: The Ove’ Glove, a Christmas cookie jar, cookie decorating kits, Amy Sedaris’ I Like You: Hospitality Under the Influence, a cookie apron, etc. I tend to think a little competition is good for morale.
As I mentioned, this is a popular party idea. So, if you’ve hosted your own Cookie Exchange in the past, I’d love to hear any suggestions you might have to make mine even better.
Recent Comments